An employee on probation that is dismissed unfairly in Ireland, and wants to take a case, may have a difficulty relying on the primary legislation in this area being the Unfair Dismissals Acts when taking an unfair dismissal claim for dismissal during a probationary period.
The same is true for an employee with under one year service period with an employer.
However, there are options available for this employee type listed below.
Unfair Dismissals Acts
If an employee is dismissed from their place of employment, they are entitled to commence an unfair dismissals action against their former employer.
The law states the dismissal of an employee shall be deemed for the purposes of this Act (Unfair Dismissals Act) to be an unfair dismissal unless, having regard to all the circumstances, there were substantial grounds justifying the dismissal.
Burden of Proof – Unfair Dismissal Ireland Cases
In determining for the purposes of this Act whether the dismissal of an employee was an unfair dismissal or not, its for the employer to show that the dismissal resulted because of one or more of the matters specified in Section 6 of the Unfair Dismissals Act (as amended).
The employers conduct in terms of the reason for the dismissal and any investigation procedures, disciplinary procedures, and sanctions will be assessed by an Adjudication officer in a case.
Dismissal During Probation or Year One
A problem arises though for an employee seeking to rely on the primary legislation being the Unfair Dismissals Act when the employee was on probation, or if the dismissal occurred during the first year of employment.
Section 3 of the Unfair Dismissals Act states the following:
This Act shall not apply in relation to the dismissal of an employee during a period starting with the commencement of the employment when he is on probation or undergoing training—
(a) if his contract of employment is in writing, the duration of the probation or training is 1 year or less and is specified in the contract, or
(b) if his contract of employment was made before the commencement of this Act and was not in writing and the duration of the probation or training is 1 year or less.
So, relying on the Unfair Dismissals acts for an employee dismissed while on probation or during their first year in employment is a difficult task.
There is caselaw on this regarding claims taken by employees on probation and dismissed, and without the one year service period requirement under the Unfair Dismissals acts, where the complainants won their cases, but we will discuss this in another post.
So, what can employees on probation, or with less than the one year service period requirement who are unfairly dismissed do ?.
Unfair Dismissal Claim
The employee may have the option of taking an unfair dismissal claim. There is a challenge for the applicant to take a case, in the above-mentioned circumstance, under the Unfair Dismissals Acts, but applicants with under the 1 year service period have been successful taking such claims.
Industrial Relations Act 1969
Some employers seem to be content that they don’t have to treat employees fairly, like they would do if that employee had the one year service period completed, and hence attract the legal protection of the Unfair Dismissals Acts.
Any employee unfairly dismissed on probation, or during their first year with the employer, can still seek a legal remedy for the unfair dismissal.
Section 13 of the Industrial Relations Act 1969 states:
Where a trade dispute (other than a dispute connected with rates of pay of, hours or times of work of, or annual holidays of, a body of workers) exists or is apprehended and involves workers within the meaning of Part VI of the Principal Act, a party to the dispute may refer it to a rights commissioner.
An employee can refer a dispute to the Workplace Relations Commission under this act.
If a dismissal arose which is discrimination under one of the grounds in the Equality Act, an employee on probation, or with less than one years service, can take a legal action under the Equality Acts, which is a useful remedy option for the employee to invoke.
Disclaimer of Unfair Dismissal Ireland – Probation
Please be advised that the above-mentioned material is intended as an overview and as a broad out-line of the topic discussed. It should not be considered as complete and comprehensive legal advice, nor act as an appropriate substitute. Legal advice should be sought from a solicitor prior to relying on anything in this article.
Due care has been taken in the publication of this article and we do not accept legal liability as a result of reliance on any material covered in the above article.
Employment Law Articles
- Employment Law Ireland
- Unfair Dismissal Solicitors
- Protected Disclosures
- Constructive Dismissal Ireland
- Redundancy Ireland
- Bullying at the Workplace
- Workplace Harassment
- Discrimination at the Workplace
- Disciplinary Meetings & Fairness
- Deduction from Wages – Employment Law
- Dyslexia Discrimination at the Workplace
- Disability Discrimination at the Workplace
- Discrimination – Interview Process
- Disciplinary Procedure & Unfair Dismissal
- Workplace Investigations Ireland
- Age Discrimination in the Workplace
- Redundancy & Maternity Leave
- Redundancy Ireland Guide
- Redundancy Calculator Ireland
- Selection Criteria for Redundancy & Performance
- Selection Criteria for Redundancy & Genuine Consultation
- Redundancy & Temporary Lay-Offs
- Unfair Selection for Redundancy
- Unfair Selection Process & Redundancy
- Redundancy Selection Fairness & Impersonality
- Redundancy & Consultations
- Redundancy Selection – Alternative Options
- Redundancy Claim Defence – Redeployment
- Retirement Ages & Discrimination
- Sick Leave & Covid-19
- Sick Leave & Dismissal
- Gross Misconduct & Dismissal
- Annual Leave Entitlement
- Dismissal while on Sick Leave
- Calculating Loss in Unfair Dismissal Claims
- Unfair Dismissal Ireland – Probation
- Disability Discrimination Ireland
- Unfair Dismissal Claim – Employee Duty to Mitigate Loss
- Employee Verbal Warning Appeal
- Employer Delays Bullying Investigation
- Epilepsy Discrimination at the Workplace
- Disciplinary Meetings – Employment Law
- Filling out Workplace Relations Complaint Form
- Fixed-Term Employee & Pregnancy Dismissal
- Fixing Retirement Ages
- Statutory Break Entitlements
- Redundancy Selection in Ireland
- Redundancy Selection Criteria Matrix
- Time Limits – Cases
- Transfer of Undertakings
- Student Discrimination
- Severance Agreements & Tax Advice
- Terms of Employment 5 Day Rule
- Text Message & Disciplinary Meetings
- Transfer of Undertaking
- Unfair Dismissal Claim- Dismissal in Dispute
- Compensation for Unfair Dismissal
- Unfair Dismissal Claim & CCTV
- Unfair Dismissal Ireland Claim – Three Pillars
- Workplace Statutory Rest Periods
- Gardai & Employment Disputes
- Gender Dismissal Discrimination
- Grievance Procedures & Constructive Dismissal
- Guide for Employees in Redundancy Selection Process
- Maternity Leave & Salary
- New Postponement Guidelines WRC
- Legal Representation at Disciplinary Hearings
- Part-Time Workers
- Plumbers & Pipefitters
- Pre-emptory Dismissal
- Pregnancy related Discrimination
- Pregnancy related Unfair Dismissal
- Proving Fairness in Unfair Dismissal Actions
- Race Discrimination in the Workplace
- Red Circling Defence
- Workplace Relations Commission
- Employment Notice Periods
- 3 Ingredients to Prove Workplace Victimization
- Christmas Bonus for Employees
- Covid-19 Force Majeure Leave
- Redundancy Ireland & Covid-19
- Defence to Disability Discrimination Claim Ireland
- Workplace Discrimination – Gender & Family Status ground
- Discrimination on a Licensed Premises
- Discrimination in Schools
- Employers Guide to Defending Unfair Dismissal Ireland
- Temporary Lay-Off & Covid 19
- Temporary Lay-off & Non-Payment of Wages
- Severance Agreement & Legal Advice
- Unfair Dismissal Claim – Mitigating Loss